American Federation of Teachers - A Union of Professionals

Skip directly to:

AFT - A Union of ProfessionalsTeachersHigher EducationPSRPPublic EmployeesHealthcareRetireesEarly Childhood Educators

Home > Hot Topics > Standards-Based Reform >

State-by-State Analysis: New York

    Print 


Elementary

Middle

High School

Elementary

Middle

High School

Standards
The table below indicates the content the AFT looks for when reviewing English, math, science, and social studies standards. Standards that are clear and specific at the elementary, middle, and high school levels are shaded as indicated in the legend above. Standards that do not meet our criteria remain clear or "empty." Refer to the Content Standards link at the right to read our complete criteria for evaluating standards.

English

Reading Basics

Reading Comprehension

Writing Conventions

Writing Forms

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Math

Number Sense

Measurement

Geometry

Algebra

Data Analysis

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Science

Earth Science

Physical Science

Life Science

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Social Studies

Civics

U.S. History

World History

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Updated 8/2004 

Curriculum & Instruction
The table below identifies the components of a standards-based curriculum. If the components are present the appropriate levels—elementary, middle, and high school—are shaded as indicated in the legend above. If the components are missing, than the graphic remains clear or "empty." Refer to the Curriculum & Instruction link at the right to read our complete criteria for evaluating standards-based curriculum materials.

 

English

Math

Science

Social Studies

Learning Continuum

Elementary

None

None

Elementary, Middle and High

Instructional Resources

Elementary, Middle and High

None

None

Elementary, Middle and High

Instructional Strategies

Elementary

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Performance Indicators

Performance descriptors

None

None

None

None

Rubrics / scoring guides

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Middle and High School

Elementary and High School

Sample student work

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Commentary on student work

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Lesson Plans

Specifies standards addressed

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

None

Elementary, Middle and High

Specifies prior knowledge needed

None

None

None

None

Integrates two or more standards

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

None

Elementary, Middle and High

Indicates necessary materials

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

None

Elementary, Middle and High

Includes classroom assessments

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

None

Elementary, Middle and High

Indicates length of time needed

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

None

None

Includes sample student work and rubrics

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

None

Elementary, Middle and High

Provides instructional guidance

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

None

None

Includes instructional strategies for diverse learners

None

Elementary, Middle and High

None

None

Updated 11/2001

Assessing Student Performance
The table below indicates the features of an "open" or transparent assessment system that is based on the content standards. If the features are present the appropriate levels—elementary, middle, and high school—are shaded as indicated in the legend above. If the features are missing, than the graphic remains clear or "empty." Refer to the Assessing Student Performance link at the right to read our complete criteria for evaluating open and aligned testing systems.

 

English

Math

Science

Social Studies

Grades assessed

4, 8, High School

4, 8, High School

4, 8, High School

4, 8, High School

Alignment report available

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

State indicates standards tested

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

State indicates number of items per standard

None

None

None

None

Test or sample items released

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Released items indicate standard tested

None

None

None

None

State provides grade-specific performance level descriptors

None

None

None

None

State provides rubrics

High School

None

None

None

State releases scored student work

High School

High School

High School

High School

Released student work includes scorer commentary

High School

High School

High School

High School

Updated 4/2004

Accountability
The table below indicates the elements of a student accountability policy. If the elements are present, the appropriate levels—elementary, middle, and high school—are shaded as indicated in the legend above. If the elements are missing, than the graphic remains clear or "empty." Refer to the Accountability link at the right to read our complete criteria for evaluating student accountability policies.

 

English

Math

Science

Social Studies

State requires academic intervention for struggling students

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

Elementary, Middle and High

State funds academic intervention for struggling students

Promotion from grade to grade in elementary or middle school and/or graduation from high school is based, in part, on state test results

High School

High School

High School

High School

Students can earn awards for meeting higher standards

High School

High School

High School

High School

Updated 11/2001

 

 


Documents Reviewed

Early Literacy Profile: An Assessment Instrument, 1998 (curriculum)

English Language Arts Resource Guide with Core Curriculum (standards, curriculum)

English Language Arts Test Sampler Draft: Grades 4 and 8, 1998 (curriculum)

General Information: Elementary/Intermediate Levels, 2004 (assessments)

General Information: High School, 2004 (assessments)

Global History and Geography Regents Examination Test Sampler Draft, 1999 (curriculum)

Grade 5 Elementary Social Studies Test Sampler Draft, 2000 (curriculum)

Grade 8 Intermediate Social Studies Test Sampler Draft, 2000 (curriculum)

Learning Standards for English Language Arts (standards, curriculum)

Learning Standards for Mathematics, Science and Technology (standards, curriculum)

Learning Standards for Social Studies (standards, curriculum)

Mathematics: A Regents Examination Test Sampler Draft, 1998 (curriculum)

Mathematics Resource Guide with Core Curriculum  (standards, curriculum)

Mathematics, Science and Technology Resource Guide (standards)

Mathematics Test Sampler Draft: Grade 4, 1998 (curriculum)

Mathematics Test Sampler Draft: Grade 8, 1998 (curriculum)